You’ve gathered a couple of home insurance quotes. The prices are almost identical. Great—decision made, right?

Maybe. But before you pick one, take another look at what each quote actually includes. Insurance has a talent for hiding the important differences a few pages away from the price.

You don’t need to become an insurance expert. You do need to know which questions to ask. Here’s where we’d start if you brought two quotes into our Winnipeg office.

1. Start with what’s covered

The names of two policies can sound similar while their terms differ. Look at the coverage for the home itself, your belongings, personal liability and additional living expenses if an insured loss makes your home temporarily unlivable. Then check the details attached to each.

Ask: “If the same thing happened to my home, how would these two policies respond?” That’s a much more useful question than “Which one is cheaper?”

An insurance broker can help explain the types of coverage available and the optional coverage that may fit your needs. Insurance Bureau of Canada’s guide to buying home insurance is a good starting point, too.

2. Check the limits

A limit is the most a policy will pay for a particular type of covered loss, subject to the policy wording. Two quotes might have different limits for the same item. There can also be special limits for certain belongings, such as jewellery or fine art.

Don’t stop at the headline amount. If you’ve finished a basement, bought expensive equipment or made significant changes to your home, tell your broker. Those details help us ask whether the limits and coverage still make sense for your situation.

The question to ask: “Are there any limits here I might be surprised by?”

3. Look at the deductible

Your deductible is the amount you’re responsible for paying toward a covered claim. A higher deductible can affect the premium, but it also changes what you would pay out of pocket after a loss.

Compare the deductibles side by side. Ask whether a separate deductible applies to a particular type of claim. Then consider the practical question: “Would I be comfortable paying that amount tomorrow?”

The cheapest premium is less appealing if it comes with a deductible you didn’t notice.

4. Ask about water coverage

This is especially worth a conversation when you have a basement. Don’t assume the word “water” on a quote answers every water-damage question.

For example, sewer backup and overland flood are distinct coverages. They are not automatically included in every home policy and may be available as options, depending on the insurer and property. The Insurance Bureau of Canada notes this distinction.

Ask your broker:

  • Is sewer backup included? If so, what limit and deductible apply?
  • Is overland water or flood coverage available for this property? What are its terms?
  • Are there conditions or exclusions I should know about?

A checked box is only the beginning of the conversation. The limit and wording matter.

5. Read the exclusions and added coverages

An exclusion describes something the policy does not cover. An endorsement can add, change or restrict coverage. These are not exactly beach reading, but they can explain why two similar-looking quotes are different.

You don’t have to decipher every line alone. Ask someone to point out the exclusions and optional coverages that matter for your home. For a plain-language explanation of declarations, deductibles, endorsements and exclusions, see IBC’s guide to knowing your policy.

6. Make sure the quotes describe the same home

Before comparing the answers, compare the questions the insurers were given. Are both quotes based on the same address, property details, use of the home and requested coverages?

Tell your broker about material changes, including renovations, a home-based business or renting out part of the property. An attractive quote based on incomplete information is not a useful comparison. If something on a quote looks wrong, get it corrected before you make a decision.

A quick way to compare two quotes

Put them beside each other and ask for a short explanation of:

CheckWhat to ask
PremiumWhat is the total cost and payment arrangement?
Main coverage and limitsWhat is included, and where are the caps?
DeductiblesWhat would I pay toward a covered claim?
Water coverageWhich types are included, available or excluded?
Exclusions and endorsementsWhat changes the usual coverage?
Property detailsAre both quotes based on accurate, matching information?

That’s a better starting point than judging two policies by the annual price alone.

We can help you sort it out

Buying insurance probably wasn’t your plan for a fun afternoon. Fair enough.

Fast Insurance is locally owned and operated in Winnipeg. We work with multiple insurance markets and can help you compare the options available for your home in plain language. If you have an existing policy or a couple of quotes and aren’t sure what you’re looking at, get in touch with our Winnipeg team. We’ll help you figure out which questions are worth asking—and what the answers mean.

This article is general information. Coverage, limits, exclusions, availability and pricing depend on the insurer, policy wording and your circumstances. Review the actual documents with a licensed broker before making a change.